Etsy Fee Calculator vs Amazon Seller Margin Calculator
Etsy charges a combination of listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing, and optional offsite ads fees. Amazon charges referral fees by category, potential FBA fulfillment fees, and a monthly subscription for professional sellers. The better platform depends on your product type, price point, fulfillment preference, and how you plan to drive traffic.
Quick Decision
Choose Etsy if you sell handmade, vintage, or niche craft products and want a lower barrier to entry. Choose Amazon if you sell commodity or branded products at scale and want access to a massive built-in customer base with fulfillment infrastructure.
When to Use Etsy Fee Calculator
- You sell handmade, custom, or vintage products that fit Etsy's marketplace identity.
- You want to start selling with minimal upfront cost and no monthly subscription.
- Your products command premium pricing because of their uniqueness or craftsmanship.
- You are comfortable handling your own shipping, packaging, and customer service.
When to Use Amazon Seller Margin Calculator
- You sell branded or commodity products that benefit from Amazon's massive customer base.
- You want fulfillment handled for you through FBA so you can focus on sourcing and marketing.
- Your products compete well on price and you can maintain margins at higher referral fee rates.
- You plan to scale volume quickly and need infrastructure that supports high-order throughput.
Example Scenarios
A jewelry maker selling handmade earrings at $35 each would likely keep more profit on Etsy, where the niche audience values craftsmanship and the fee structure is straightforward. On Amazon, referral fees plus FBA costs could consume a large portion of the low price point.
A seller sourcing phone accessories at $3 each and selling at $15 would benefit more from Amazon's traffic volume and FBA convenience. Etsy's audience is not searching for commodity electronics accessories, so traffic would be minimal.
A candle maker selling $25 soy candles could succeed on either platform but should calculate the exact fee impact. On Etsy, total fees would be roughly $2.80 per sale. On Amazon with FBA, referral fees plus fulfillment could reach $7-9 per unit depending on size and weight.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Tools
Related Calculators
- Etsy Fee Calculator
Calculate your real Etsy profit after listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing, and offsite ads.
- Amazon Seller Margin Calculator
Calculate Amazon seller profit margin after referral fees, FBA fees, storage, and shipping costs.
- Break-Even Calculator
Calculate your break-even point in units and revenue, contribution margin, and units needed for a target profit.
- Markup vs Margin Calculator
Convert between markup and margin percentages, calculate selling prices, and see the difference between markup and profit margin.
- Side Hustle Profit Estimator
Estimate side-hustle profit, after-tax profit, hourly profit, and retained percentage using transparent planning assumptions.
Related Guides
- How Etsy Fees Work: A Complete Breakdown for Sellers
A clear explanation of every fee Etsy charges sellers, including listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing fees, and offsite ads fees, with a worked example showing the total cost of a typical sale.
- Markup vs Margin: What's the Difference and Why It Matters
This guide explains the difference between markup and profit margin, shows the formulas for each, demonstrates how to convert between them, and highlights common pricing mistakes that come from confusing the two.
- How to Calculate Your Break-Even Point
This guide explains break-even analysis from the ground up, covering fixed costs, variable costs, contribution margin, and the break-even formula, with practical examples for small business owners.